Humans have been able to communicate using some form of language for at least 150,000 years. So, isn’t it odd that most of us still find it emotionally challenging to certain types of conversations e.g., those during which we need to tell someone that we’d like to experience a change in how they behave or speak? Shouldn’t 150,000 years of practice have made perfect? Many of us envy the few who can ‘talk straight’. But even those who can easily deliver tough messages often find it difficult to receive them! Why is that? We typically refer to those as “difficult questions.” That suggests that it is the conversation that is the problem. But, perhaps it is how we handle them that is the issue.
The human brain evolved to cater for a much simpler world than we now experience. It evolved to ensure our survival when ensuring shelter, safety, sustenance and reproduction were the sole concerns. It developed to detect threats and trigger appropriate responses … at speed! A significant component of safety comes from tribal behaviour – seeking out those likely to support us and then gaining and sustaining that support. We developed the ability to almost instantaneously spot those who were potential tribe members and those who posed potential threats. The resulting behaviours could have dramatic consequences.
Many of us have watched in wonder nature programs wherein, for some tiny reason, a young chick, penguin or other animal has been rejected by its parents or social group. We watch in amazement at how it is left to fend for itself and ultimately suffer and even die. But, how often do we then reflect on the fact that earlier that same day, through clumsy or inappropriate use of language, we may well have done something analogous to a member of staff or colleague? The importance of creating an inclusive culture has been high on the business agenda for many years now. A sense of isolation or exclusion is now known to be a significant trigger for anxiety, depression and, at an extreme, suicidal thoughts. As a bare minimum it leads to reduced engagement and productivity, both critical issues in many organisations today.
To protect ourselves from perceived threats, our brains evolved the 4F responses of Fight, Flight, Freeze, and Flock:
- Fight – use strength to beat off the attack (real or not)
- Flight – know when you might lose and get away
- Freeze – you might not be noticed and the threat will go somewhere else
- Flock – quickly gather supporters for a joint and strong response.
We all have the same basic survival wiring in our brains. But, the good news is that these are being modified from the second we are born to the last second of our mortal life. This is how we develop and modulate our personal biases and instinctive responses to the world around us. Our experiences are constantly adapting our perceptions of situations and adjusting how we should respond. Fortunately, most of this modification process helps us to learn how to thrive in our respective environments. It is even the process by which we learn to perform complex tasks like walking, speaking, driving, reading.
But, some experiences can lead to us finding certain conversations difficult e.g.,
- Our parents or guardians might not have demonstrated effective communications
- Our parents or guardians may have taught us ‘to speak only when spoken to’ or ‘not to be rude to your elders and superiors’ or ‘don’t answer back’
- We may have been taught not to argue or to always do as we are told
- Childhood experience may have triggered a fear of losing a valued relationship
- We simply like the response we get to “people-pleasing”
- We fear legal ramifications if we are perceived to have offended someone.
Conversations typically feel difficult because the parties have different perceptions of what was, is or should be the reality. This can arise from:
- having had different experiences (each viewing our own experience as the truth);
- holding different beliefs and values about what is right and wrong;
- having different expectations of each other;
- having made different assumptions, often about the other’s intentions;
- sudden changes to expectations or realities.
We now know that most people, especially those who are employed, seek four things:
- Clarity
- Assurance
- Recognition
- Empathy.
Over the past few decades, great strides have been made to prepare new generations to speak up; to be confident; to take a stand; to have the courage of their convictions. And, more recently, the development of email, texting, and social media have equipped us to share our thoughts more directly and more quickly. You may have thought this would have helped – enabling us to meet that primary need of clarity at least. But, there is growing evidence that ‘communicating at a distance’ may have made things worse. The cognitive disconnect and emotional distancing involved make it so much easier for these interactions to feel highly critical and to trigger the corresponding negative reactions i.e., Assurance, Recognition and Empathy are suffering and the 4Fs still characterise the impact of many of our conversations. Given what we now know about society, relationships, etc, why do we not handle difficult conversations better and avoid those 4Fs in the first place?
The answer lies largely in the speed at which our brain operates and the power of the chemical reactions that are generated. The parts of the brain that process logical thoughts operate dramatically slower than those that operate instinctively by a ratio of around 140 : 11 million. But, all is not lost. We can, with practice, identify the situations that trigger our and others’ 4F responses. When initiating what could be a difficult conversation with others, we can create an environment that suppresses them. We can learn to pause and avoid those 4Fs when we are on the receiving end of a difficult conversation. Effectively, we can learn a fifth F standing for Fathom or ‘Fathom out what is happening before initiating or responding to a potentially difficult conversation’.
In our upcoming Handling difficult conversations lunchtime webinar, we will explore these thoughts in more detail and provide advice on how to handle difficult conversations more effectively.
Clinton Wingrove – Principal Consultant, Clinton HR Ltd
clinton@clintonhr.com, +44 (0)785 225 8976
Photo by SHVETS production: https://www.pexels.com/photo/crop-unrecognizable-female-psychologist-and-patient-discussing-mental-problems-during-session-7176319/